• Bloomcole@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    why and how would smokers contribute more?
    As I said, taxes are extremely high on tobacco. 85%
    Even disregarding the amount in general taxes smokers also pay for healthcare that alone is more than the cost of smoking to healthcare.
    Unfortunately couldn’t find the study I read but it came down to a few 100 million surplus (in NL).

    And yes not needing to pay pensions is a big part of the gains to to the state but also not having to pay for the plethora of other diseases the elderly invariably get.
    And while obese people indeed have premature mortality that is often preceded by decades of chronic illnesses and care.
    And same as smokers that includes increased risk of cancers.
    Unlike most smokers very obese people often can’t perform physical labor the average human can.
    There’s more, like logistics and how many hospital workers and specialized ambulances or equipment it takes to simply move the more extreme cases but I think this will do.
    To be clear, I’m not defending smoking but the argument of how they don’t want to help smokers (basically addicts and victims) because it costs their health system is wrong.
    Not to mention anti-social and selfish.
    As I mentioned in the other comment, that’s a slippery slope.