Posting in case this helps someone else. This Leaps and Bounds cherry toy was the very first toy I bought for her as a kitten, and she must have imprinted on it, as six years later it is still the ONLY toy she will play with.

A photo taken from above of a tiny brown and white tabby kitten on a wood floor next to a pair of mesh cherry toys

They’re rather fragile, easy to crush if stepped on, and fall apart after a few months of regular play. Knowing how much she loved them I would grab spares whenever I could, but a few years ago they went out of stock and didn’t come back.

Every time I brought out a fresh cherry from the dwindling stash she would get SO excited, so I searched high and low, desperate to find more. If you read the reviews on Petco, there’s other people with cats who’ve fixated on these cherries, and I found similar threads on Reddit.

It’s been years, but I still search semi-regularly, and imagine my joy when I realized they were back in stock! Stupidly, it’s listed as part of a random assortment, so I decided to order 100 of them, hoping for a third to be cherries but happy to get any at all.

A hand holding a ziplock bag full of cherry toys with "32 pairs" written on it

32 pairs - 64 cherries! A lifetime supply of her favorite toy for my picky little baby <3

A brown and white tabby cat curled up on a fleece blanket next to a cherry toy